Skip to content

MigrationsSubstack

Move your newsletter from Substack to Shipmail

Export the list from Substack, upload the file to Shipmail, and check the import plan before anything is created. Nobody gets an email until you send one.

Julien Coulaud on X

Founder of Shipmail, the email platform for businesses and their AI agents. Every guide here draws on mail servers running in production.

  • Substack
  • Newsletters
  • Migration

Short answer

In Substack, open Settings, create a new export and download the zip. It holds your posts and your subscriber list. Upload it under Newsletters > Migrations in Shipmail: subscribers and past posts come in, nothing is sent, and new issues go out from your own domain instead of substack.com.

Export your list from Substack

  1. Step 1

    Open the export section

    In Substack, open Settings and find the export section in the left navigation. Substack labels it Exports or Import/Export.

  2. Step 2

    Create the export

    Click Create new export. Substack builds a zip file of your publication.

  3. Step 3

    Download the zip

    Download the file from the same section when it is ready.

  4. Step 4

    Or export only the list

    On the Subscribers page, under All subscribers, open the three-dot menu above the list and choose Export to get a CSV.

Sources[1]Substack Help: how do I export my posts?[2]Substack Help: how do I export my email list?

The full export is a zip with your posts, your subscriber list and its statistics. The subscriber CSV can have all columns or only the visible ones.Sources[1]Substack Help: how do I export my posts?[2]Substack Help: how do I export my email list?

Import it into Shipmail

  1. Step 1

    Open Newsletters > Migrations

    Upload the Substack export as it came, up to 500 MB. Shipmail recognizes the format and lists the audiences and past newsletters it found.

  2. Step 2

    Review the import plan

    Pick the audiences to bring, rename them, and check how each column maps to a Shipmail field.

  3. Step 3

    Confirm consent and start

    Confirm the people on the list agreed to hear from you, then start the import. You can close the page while it runs.

[3]

The import never sends an email. You can undo it for seven days unless someone edited the imported data, and unsubscribes stay in place when you do.[3]

What moves and what stays behind

  • Subscribers from the email list.
  • Unsubscribed, bounced and complained addresses, which stay excluded from every send.
  • Other columns, such as subscription type, as fields on each contact.
  • Past posts, as private imported newsletters that cannot be sent again and stay out of feeds.
[3]

What stays behind:

  • Paid subscriptions and their Stripe billing. Shipmail has no paid newsletters.
  • Substack's network: recommendations, Notes, chats and the app.
  • Comments on past posts.
  • Open and click history from past sends.

What Substack and Shipmail cost

A weekly newsletter to 10,000 subscribers sends 40,000 emails a month. Shipmail's cheapest option for that volume is $24 (Solo with 100,000 more sends), billed monthly, with mailboxes on your domain and no subscriber limit. On Substack the same list costs $0 a month, billed monthly. Substack costs $288 less over a year.Sources[4]Shipmail pricing[5]Substack Help: how much does Substack cost?

Substack is free to publish on. It takes 10% of paid subscription revenue, and Stripe charges its own fees on top.[5]

Every plan has unlimited subscribers and is priced by newsletter sends: Solo includes 10,000 a month, Pro 25,000 and Team 100,000, and more sends cost $20 a month per 100,000 or $149 per 1,000,000. Try your own list size in the newsletter cost calculator.[4]

Sources6 sourcesVerified 2026-11-16
  1. [1]
    Substack Help: how do I export my posts?

    In Settings, the export section (Exports or Import/Export) has Create new export, which builds a zip of the publication's posts, subscriber list and statistics to download from the same section. The help centre blocks automated fetches; read through search results on 2026-11-14.

    support.substack.com · 2026-11-14

  2. [2]
    Substack Help: how do I export my email list?

    On the Subscribers page, under All subscribers, the three-dot menu above the list has Export, which downloads a CSV with all columns or only the visible ones. Read through search results on 2026-11-14.

    support.substack.com · 2026-11-14

  3. [3]
    Shipmail newsletter migrations documentation

    Upload a newsletter export up to 500 MB. Mailchimp, Substack, beehiiv and Ghost content and contacts import; Brevo, Kit, MailerLite, Constant Contact and Campaign Monitor contact exports import. Unsubscribes, bounces and complaints take precedence, imports never start a send, and an import can be undone for seven days.

    shipmail.to · 2026-10-15

  4. [4]
    Shipmail pricing

    Shipmail plan prices, mailbox limits, team access, and send limits.

    shipmail.to · 2026-11-16

  5. [5]
    Substack Help: how much does Substack cost?

    Publishing is free. Substack takes 10% of paid subscription revenue, and Stripe charges its own payment fees. Connecting a custom domain is an optional one-time $50 fee. The help center blocks automated fetches; read through search results on 2026-10-19.

    support.substack.com · 2026-10-19

  6. [6]
    Substack Help: set up a custom domain

    A custom domain costs a one-time $50 and changes the publication's web address only. Newsletters are still sent from yoursubdomain@substack.com. Read through search results on 2026-10-19.

    support.substack.com · 2026-10-19

Questions worth answering

Common questions about moving a newsletter from Substack.

Will my subscribers get an email when I import them?
No. The import creates audiences and private copies of past newsletters only. Nothing goes out until you write and send a newsletter.[3]
Can I keep sending from Substack while I set up Shipmail?
Yes. Exporting changes nothing in Substack. Send your last issue there, import the list, and send the next one from Shipmail. If people subscribe on Substack in between, add them to the Shipmail audience with a CSV import.
Why move a free Substack newsletter?
Substack sends every newsletter from a substack.com address, even with a custom web address. Shipmail sends from a subdomain of your own domain, and replies reach a mailbox on the same plan.[6]

Related

More on moving from Substack and what Shipmail costs.

Email, newsletters and booking pages on your own domain, in one plan.

Get started for free